So I heard news about there being a movie made about the Giver, and naturally I decided to re-read the book after people harassed me over not giving it a glowing five star review. Originally I read the book earlier this year in April, and I was not a fan but I didn’t hate it. But I decided to give it another chance to see if it could go from being a three star to possibly a four or five star book. Sadly this book stayed at being a solid three stars for me. I did read the book twice, yet I feel like I have to apologize to its fans for not liking the book enough to give it the five stars.
Before I read the Giver, I have read many science fiction books such as the Hunger Games trilogy, Divergent, the Handmaid’s Tale, Ender’s Game, the Host, Gathering Blue and who knows how many other books I’ve read in that genre. After reading science-fiction and fantasy for almost a decade, it would take something really different to get me to say “wow.” Compared to other works the Giver was okay. For me I give books three stars if it was an okay read.
But for the children’s section, I feel like the Giver was one of the best children’s books I’ve read as an adult. Compared to a lot of children’s books, the Giver asks and brings up a lot of questionable themes that most do not. For that I actually do like about the Giver because it’s really rare to find science fiction for younger readers. I think with the other three companion books (Gathering Blue, Messenger and Son) the Giver would stand better as a series than as an individual book, since I would then give the series as a whole a higher rating.
As a side note, I would really hate to live in a world without individuality. That was one thing that kept bugging me while I read the book. If I lived in that community, I would be one of the first ones to run away since I felt like the way the people lived their lives was a bit unnatural. I like to be able to choose what I like to do, and that would definitely not be good for me to live in that kind of community.